Skip to content

Film vs digital, still??

How can people still have this debate?

Someone on a forum said that the 3 in the Nikon D3 should stand for 3rd generation of digital photography.

“1st Generation - the introduction of the digital workflow - making the dark-room obsolete

2nd Generation - outperforming film in quality - making film obsolete

3rd Generation - Changing the paradigm of light in photography, removing the need for flash photography and even unnatural studio lighting; making the flash dead and perhaps the tripod too?”

Okay, I can *sort of* agree with the 1st generation.. maybe in that it made it less of a necessity to get into photography. Then again, I’m probably one of the few who actually likes the smell of photo chemicals. But this person’s 2nd generation definition… really? Digital has nothing on film. I’m surprised that in 2008 more people don’t realize that.. or maybe they don’t care. Which if that’s the case, good. It’s one of those things you shouldn’t waste your time thinking about. (Note: this is not taking into account medium or large format film. game over, period)

I think this is what pushed me back to shooting film.. I got tired of hearing people whine about dynamic range, the photosite width, bayer interpolation. I’ve got better things to do, you know? I guess you could say, why even listen to those people? Good question. I think because I’m a more technical person, I tend to get upset more easily about those types of issues than people who don’t.

Film rules, digital drools.

No, I’m playing.. I think both are fine, just depends what you really want out of it.

Lightning outside my window.

Blowin’ trees

Tree on Hawk Hill, San Francisco

Actually that tree was standing still, but a tree that I’m sure blows sometimes.. right? If I had my light meter, I would be able to tell you what I shot this at, all I know is that it was Velvia 50 film.

Speaking of my light meter, here’s a fun story.

I was told about the equinox and how the moon was to rise over San Francisco, but this wasn’t an ordinary moonrise.. it was going to be huge. Bigger than life type shit. I scouted a location on yahoogle maps (It’s the best!), got in my janky Hyundai rental car and headed out towards the Golden Gate bridge.. finding the spot was easy. Parked my whip, hopped out with my hot-ass chick (justing kidding, there was no hot-ass chick, I’m just hearing R. Kelly in my head) and headed up the path to the top of the hill, which later I came to find out was called Hawk Hill. There are some people up there setting up, and I still had about 45 minutes of daylight left so I walked around for awhile. I found this nice overlook of the hills and whipped out my F6. During this, I pulled out my light meter (Sekonic 758dr) and was toying around with the ambient meter. I zipped it up in it’s pouch and put it away after I was finished. Sun starts to go down so I move over to where the other photographers have their stuff set up and I peeped some really nice color bands in the clouds so I finished off that roll and then pulled out my digital camera and started futzing around. I’ve really started to loathe using it for anything landscape related but that’s neither here nor there. About 20 minutes later cops roll up and tell everyone to leave because the place closes at sunset. Not interested in getting a ticket or my car towed, I gathered my stuff and went back down the path. I went back the way I came and drove closer to the bridge, right as I round this bend I see the moon and DAMN it’s huge! Like, holding a basketball above your head and looking at the sky type shit. I found a spot to park and walked over near this point and it was freezing, had to be at least 20 degrees cooler than the top of the hill, one mile away. I shoot a few shots but it was too cold and I was not prepared in the least. Back at the car, I realize that my light meter is gone. F*@#!!!!! I hauled ass back up the road and parked as close as I could since they closed the gate to the top of the hill. I ran up this road and I could feel it get warmer.. it was awesome. I whip out my phone and turn the brightness all the way up, but nothing. I knew of 3 places I stood and opened my bag so I went to them twice each. Nothing. I couldn’t believe it. How could I have been so careless? I walked down the hill, hating myself and thinking about how I would replace it. I thought I’d make a craigslist post just to be safe. I made it back to the car and drove the longest drive back to the hotel. I couldn’t even muster the energy to go get hammered in the Redwood Room because, what’s the point? I’d probably lose my credit cards or something.

I made a posting (with a reward even!) as soon as I got upstairs, and never heard a peep. Sad. :( When I was trying to look something up related to work in my gmail, I couldn’t believe my eyes… someone had found my light meter! I quickly emailed back and then realized there was a number there so I called and this wonderful woman answered the phone and I meekly said “Hey, I’m uh calling about my lost light meter I posted about on craigslist.” She quickly said “Yes! I have your light meter!” and so we worked out the shipping details and that was that. I received an email from her later that night telling me what model it was, just so I could be sure that it was mine. You never know, someone else could’ve lost one as well.. though I’d hope no one was as careless as I was that night. I want to extend to most gracious thank you I can to a stranger who was so kind as to return an item that was found. You could’ve kept it for yourself, gave it to a friend, sold it for a decent chunk of change to a camera store, but no you did the right thing. Thank you, Pascale. I hope the favor is returned to you if you’re ever in need.

Really though, as a photographer, light is the most important thing we have. Without it, what are we gonna take pictures of? Now, this may seem really obvious to you, but think about it.. look at any picture.. what sets it apart from any other? Light. There are so many things to take pictures of out there and to me, they’re all pretty boring things, but throw the right light at it and it comes to life.  Shots during the middle of the day? Boring. Sunset? Better chance. Sunrise? Still better chance.

I had this whole thing written out in my head, then I had to get on a conference call for work only to find out it’s cancelled and now my head is empty. Thanks, Yahoo.

The format was supposed to be one image per post, but for the really long ones, I’m putting up two.

Oh, I just bought a used Mamiya RZ67 on ebay for a decent price. I’m looking forward to medium format.

Sunset from Hawk Hill

Things take time

Large storage tank in Williamsburg

Especially figuring out where you want to take yourself with a hobby. I’ve always been awestruck with photography, and I remember borrowing my friend Kathi’s camera to shoot hardcore shows. By 16 (I think?) I had saved up enough to buy my first camera. It was a Canon AE-1 with a 50mm f/1.2 and boy was it great. I didn’t know squat about what the hell I was doing, I was just looking for the meter needle to be in the middle. I upgraded a couple of years later to a Nikon n90s as it had this nifty feature where the SB-28 flash would sync at 1/8000. That was mind blowing to me and I just had to have them. Little did I realize how expensive this was.. the body itself was $1000. The SB-28 was like $350 or something, but I got one off of ebay along with the SC-17 extension cable. I didn’t do much with it, sadly. Shit, that just reminded me that I took a picture of this Frank Gehry building in Iowa City with T-MAX P3200.. high speed black and white film. Little did I know it was actually ISO 800 pre-pushed two stops (if I’m remembering correctly) but man, I need to track down the film strip with that image and scan it. I actually made a print of it, but the contrast was flat and it just looked spooky.. but the grain! The grain was prefect. That’s my one gripe about digital photography.. chroma noise. Barf. It just makes things look like shit. Luminance noise on the other hand is great. I see luminance noise and to me it just makes the image come alive. That being said, I shoot mostly color slide film, ISO 50/100 Velvia, Fujichrome T64 (tungsten balanced film).. Moving on.. I brought my camera with me when I moved to the East Coast, even though I didn’t really shoot that much. I think I used it at my dude Brian’s wedding. I still haven’t developed that roll of film. Oops. I basically had dropped out of photography due to poor financial standing. It’s an expensive hobby. One day though, after playing with my friend’s Nikon d70, I was like, shit I should really get back into this.. this is fun, take photo, see results instantly. Perfect! I read up on a bunch of articles online about the Nikon DSLRs because I was familiar with Nikon bodies. I chose the d200 which at the time was a hell of a camera. A button for each function, a great feeling body, a good amount of weight to it. I was sold. I spent my nights reading Ken Rockwell’s site about all the different digital bodies, how things worked, whitebalance, stuff I knew at one point but had forgotten and it all seemed to click now. What happened next I would’ve never expected.

I had started going to The Rub on New Years of 2005/2006. For those of you who don’t know, it’s a monthly hip-hop dance party in Brooklyn. By far the best party I’ve ever attended. Anyway, I’m a relatively shy person in social/party settings. I spent my 5-6 hours at this party standing against a wall enjoying the music and watching people dance. It never bothered me that I did this, but my friends would tease me for what they considered odd behavior. Fast forward to October of 2006.. It was right after Sabbath in the Park, and my first time out with my camera.. it was the Halloween Rub so it was the best time to take pictures of people.. they’re all in costume, I don’t feel guilty taking pictures that way. You may be wondering, “why the f would you feel guilty? that’s what photographers do you tool!” but in my mind, I always think of Schrodingersnge’s cat. (google it) If you’re observing, you’re affecting the outcome (this is a given), but if the subject knows you’re observing, I think it makes them react differently. This may or may not be the case all the time, but I digress. There are a lot of little details to fill in, so if you’re still with me.. thanks. It gets better, I swear.

After The Rub I emailed Ayres and said, yo here’s some pictures I took, use ‘em if you’d like. I didn’t hear anything for like a day or two but he replied and said they were great and could I come every month and take pictures. Hell yeah! The camera had me interacting with the crowd more and I was learning more about taking pictures in that type of setting as well. I knew about the partyography scene (my word.. just remember that!) but I didn’t have much of an interest as a lot of it to me seemed like people hamming it up on purpose, which is what I don’t like. I’m interested in capturing the action of the moment as it happens, not as it’s directed. Conversely, I envied the ability to do that with people, to get them to pose, to lay naked on a bathroom floor, tug at someone’s underwear with their teeth. I don’t have the guts to do that.

The more I shot The Rub, the better I got, and also the nerdier I got, I started noticing color casts due to mismatched white balance and flash lighting tends to cast towards cyan too often. I became frustrated, starting gelling my flashes and then getting stuck on what the color temp actually is now that it’s gelled and setting to tungsten white balance seemed to make things too warm. By this point I had moved on to the Canon 5D, full frame sensor, could actually use a 16mm f/2.8 and have it actually be 16mm. It’s a wonderful, but I loathe Canon’s ergonomics. The 5D is extremely clunky to use, but takes amazingly sharp and vivid pictures, whereas the D200 felt soft in comparison. I continued to learn and buy more gear, mostly to learn but also because I could. It was awesome to have an array of lenses to be able to photograph pretty much anything. I found myself slipping away from the party scene because more and more things were attracting my eye.. sunset/sunrise/nighttime city shots/stars/etc. By the time the Nikon D3 was released in early December 2007, I felt kind of disconnected. I still enjoyed shooting The Rub because it was always fun, other parties didn’t have the same kind of magic so I became frustrated, because I can’t make that magic happen, it just has to be there. I started going to other parties with my camera, but never taking it out. Then I started just not taking it at all. That was weird, because often times I’d get ask, where’s the camera? Sometimes it felt like, hey I’m a person too, you know? I’m not just the quiet guy who takes pictures.

I have no idea what even got me back to film, but I started to miss the sharpness of my 5D and rather than go out and actually buy a 5D and some lenses/flashes, I thought, film is a million times sharper than digital ever will be. (sidenote: try out the Foveon X3 sensor)

A few months prior I had bought some film and actually rode around taking some pictures, but I just didn’t get the same vibe I did with digital. I was a lot more afraid of actually firing the shutter than before. Digital really makes it too easy to screw up, fix, re-shoot. Film, you don’t see until you develop it, so it’s important to take notes and learn from that. So what, you say? People shoot film all the time! Yeah, I know you’re right, but there’s still something that’s scary about it once you’re exposed to a world that doesn’t follow the same rules.

I’ve been writing this entry for like… 3 hours I feel like. I keep getting sidetracked with work. So my apologies if this seems all over the place.

I’ve gotten myself a used Nikon F6 that I absolutely love.. with a 50mm f/1.4 attached most of the time. That’s what I shoot most stuff with, but I’ve even started using it at parties. It’s a bit different though, being unable to shoot, realize oops I need more ambient light, open aperture up a stop and reshoot. I need faster slide film, to make my flashes use less power and keep shutter speeds average so I can still get good subject lighting, with plenty of ambient light, without the huge light streaks.

What the hell is the point of this entry? I don’t really know, I just started asking myself recently, how did I even get here? Where do I want to go?

I want to go where the film is. Until digital fixes moire/softness and starts behaving like film, I’m staying put right here. That’s what you’ll see here. Film. 35mm, 6×7, maybe some large format if I ever get around to acquiring a large format. It probably won’t be a lot of party stuff, but things will be interesting nonetheless, I promise. If it’s not.. tell me. I love feedback, positive or negative. It helps me learn.

If you’ve made it this far, I thank you, and present you with one more image.

Rainbow over Union Square, NYC

I love that image. Shot with my Nikon n90s, Velvia 50.

Two Tuesdays ago it was 110 degrees in New York

110 degrees, with the heat index. It was pretty unbearable and I don’t mind the heat.. but there was talk of a thunderstorm that would break the heat wave and sure enough around 8 or 9 pm lightning started to flash in the distance. I grabbed my camera, tripod, and cable release and ran up to the roof. It was pretty windy but I managed to get about 6 frames fired off before I was drenched by the rain. This wasn’t a normal rain, but rather a rain that was absent one second and drenching everything it touched, including me. The camera was fine, I had it wrapped in a plastic bag with a hole for the lens to peek through. I was leaving for sunny California the next morning so I used as much of the roll as I could before rewinding and setting it aside for my (projected) large trip to the lab two Mondays from then. 

Lightning over the Gowanus Canal

This is my favorite shot of the night. I like the ground to air bolt behind the fence the most, which makes me realize that my favorite subject to shoot is lightning. As usual, I’ve posted the image and now I have nothing else to add. I guess that’s life.

I’m baaaaaaack!

Maybe. :)

More to come in the next week.

In the meantime, the photos went to a new url. http://photos.crewcial.org/, so if you’re here hoping to find a galley, change the crewcial.org or www.crewcial.org to photos.crewcial.org and everything should work as they should.

I enjoy messing around with things.